**This post is directly related to a conversation that my husband had recently at church. No names will be used, in order to protect the guilty.**
As a veteran homeschooler I am used to hearing alot of negative things about this choice of education and lifestyle that we have chosen. I've read plenty of other tongue-in-cheek lists from fellow moms who have been on the receiving end of ridiculous comments as well. But one thing that blows me away, even more than the ignorant comments, is the
gall that it takes to speak directly to a homeschooling parent in a negative manner, about the very thing that they believe in.
Case in point - my husband was at church, having a conversation with someone who recently asked us for some information about home education. A man, not in the conversation but standing nearby, heard what they were saying and started to give the inquiring person an ear full on the "why you shouldn't homeschool."
The great advice being offered was the
talking point "that homeschoolers can't read or write". Sadly the man was referring to a time "long ago" when his wife was teaching Sunday School, and she had some homeschooled children in there who were "way behind" the ps kids in writing. (Makes you want to say "Is that the
best you can come up with?") I mention the phrase
talking point because that is what takes place when the same words are used over and over, by a certain group of people, and it seems that they just copy one another and don't have any original thoughts about the subject. They just repeat what they've heard, without even investigating whether there is any truth to it or not.
So - let's consider some things regarding these accusations:
Yes - ps kids are taught certain skills in certain grades - whether they are physically or mentally ready or not. Years ago a random board of people came up with a scope and sequence that dictated who should do what and when it should be done. Gee. That's scientific. They based their charts on what a number of kids in that age group could do and they created a standard that quickly became "law".
Ok, let's consider this for a moment: How many of your children are exactly alike? How many of them started talking at
exactly the same age? How many of them have the same talents, the same skills, the same abilities and developed those skills and talents at
exactly the same age?
If you have more than one child, your answer is surely "none"!
Any parent with more than one child will tell you that by the time the second one came along, they marveled at how different their children were. By God's almighty hand, each child is unique!
So, why do we expect to shove 25 kids in a classroom, and count on them to be on the same skill level? It's ridiculous.
Now, let's consider that this man was telling the truth (and not just repeating nonsense):
So there were 1-2 kids that were being homeschooled and couldn't write as well or maybe as fast or maybe (this actually happened to my
1st grader at church) a child who needed help with spelling (gasp!). Is this really a valid reason to lump
ALL homeschoolers in a pile and say that
ALL homeschooled kids are behind? No! It's not valid at all!
I wonder - were the homeschooled kids judged a little more harshly than, let's say, a ps kid that was struggling? I guarantee it! Homeschooled kids are watched under a microscope. One slip up or one struggle and it's an "aha" moment!
Now, let's look at some ps facts that we are all aware of:
There are classrooms
full of kids that have been in the system for all their days and are struggling with basic skills. There are "resource" classes
created for all the kids who aren't up to par with the (and I quote with much sarcasm) "gifted and talented" kids (makes my blood boil just saying those words). And yet, they dare to pick out the one or two kids who have been educated at home, who are struggling? What hypocrites!
Kids in public school are labeled, drugged, moved to the front of the class, moved to a "special" class - all because they struggle - and yet, they constantly want to point out the kid taught at home, because he has struggles too.
It all boils down to this:
Whether in public school, homeschool or private school, there will be kids that struggle. There will be kids that are amazing in one area, but slower in another area. There will be kids who need extra help and kids who fly through without much help at all. The are all "gifted and talented"!! They are all unique!
The difference is that in the homeschooling world, we recognize that each child is unique and develops at their own pace. We recognize that each child has their talents and skills in different areas. We also recognize that there is NO value in creating a classroom of clones that do everything alike and at the same time.
You see, that's the beauty of teaching your kids at home: they have the freedom to grow and learn without labels, without being segregated to the "resource" room and made to feel stupid and like an outcast. Too bad they don't have that privilege at church. I guess that's why many homeschooling parents choose to forgo the Sunday School route. Why subject your kids to ridicule and unfair judgment in a place where they should be learning about Jesus, not being examined for their lack of skill.
So, how do you handle the skeptic? Honestly? After 13 years of doing this and listening to rude comments spoken directly to my face, I usually just shake my head and feel sorry for that person and their obvious ignorance. I am not one to think fast on my feet; my answers usually come much later when I'm at home. The times that I have spoken back, I usually get so flustered that I can feel the blood rising up my neck. I would like to say that I give an eloquent, soft-spoken, godly answer and everyone walks away feeling warm and fuzzy, but that would be a lie!
But, I can say with 100% confidence, that I've never gone up to a public school parent and proceeded to tell them what I think of their broken system. I've never questioned their kid's abilities or academic struggles or their lack of social skills (another
talking point)!
I have friends who have wonderfully talented children in public school and I desire to see those kids grow in Christ and in their futures, just like I desire that same thing for the kids in private school and the ones that homeschool. I'm not prejudiced! I love my friends and I love their kids (well most of them:) and if that's where they want to educate their children, then good for them. It doesn't make us better or worse - just different.
And that's the point.