I love my "quiet time" with the Lord and I love that He's given us His word as wisdom and guidance, but I'm one of those people who works better if I have a Bible Study going on, to guide me through the life application aspect of what I'm reading. Therefore, I'm always on the lookout for a good, topical, Bible Study to work on in the mornings.
I had recently finished one (The Frazzled Female, by Cindi Wood), so I went to LifeWay in search of my next study partner; not having any topic in mind. As I combed the shelves and the various books by various authors, one author, I noticed, definitely had the monopoly on the Bible Study area -
Beth Moore.
I'm not a huge fan of Beth Moore (did I just hear an audible "gasp"?) Did I just say that outloud? Yes! That's what I said - not a fan!
I have nothing against Beth, as a woman, I just don't care for her Bible Studies.
But, let me go back........
So, I'm at Lifeway and I'm praying on-the-spot about what God would have me study next, and I keep coming across the Beth Moore studies. I've
done several of hers,
avoided several of hers, and I still have a few that might be options, although, not being a big fan, I'm reluctant to pick one up, so I keep looking. Nothing is jumping out at me, for the simple reason that I wasn't really struggling in one particular area at the moment, so I really just wanted a simple guide through the scriptures. However, when I came to Beth's study on the Life of Jesus, it caught my attention. "This might do" I thought. I mean, how can you
embellish the life of Jesus, if you're just going through the scriptures, right? (Embellishment is one of the aspects of her studies that I don't like).
I bought the book and brought it home.
Fast forward about four days and the book is still sitting on my desk and I can't bring myself to start the work (not to worry; I was reading the story of David in 2 Samuel, so all was good with the quiet time). Finally, toward the end of the week, I open it up and start by reading the Introduction and
Day 1's lesson. It literally didn't take even getting to
Day 2, before I found it: the
embellishment and the
speculation! Ugggg! But reading on and getting to the questions at the end of
Day 1 brought even more frustration - stupid questions that don't even pertain!
YES! These are the things that keep me from doing Beth Moore Bible studies!
*
*Now since this is not a formal review, I'm not going to supply quotes of what I'm talking about, but since it is my personal opinion on my personal blog, I will elaborate to the point that my memory allows. **
The first time I felt this way about one of her books was with her ESTHER study. She embellished to the extent that it made me sick. (Yes, that's an extreme description, but accurate. ) She added ridiculous speculation about the party going on, making a mockery of the term Bible Study and I felt it was so far fetched that I threw it in the trash after the first few lessons.
Same thing happened this time. After she started speculating about Zechariah and what he was experiencing at the temple and then throwing out some ridiculous questions, I walked straight into the kitchen and tossed it in the garbage.
Why so extreme? It just didn't feel right.
But, here's my point that I really want to make about this:
Some
LOVE her studies and love
her and that's ok - to a certain extent. But, she has become more than just a good Bible Study teacher. She has become an
idol to some. How do I know this?
Just ask a group of women at your local church and they will swoon over her name, like she's the Oprah of the Christian society. Women hang on her every word, every embellishment. They take what she says at full value, without much thought. They assume that every work produced by her is truth. And, they flock to her conferences, like she's giving away "her favorite things" (like Oprah).
Has God anointed her to speak to women? It seems so. Has he given her a gift to share with women? It seems so. However, I caution those who are following her to such an extreme extent, that she is
just a woman - flesh and bone. She can be "off" some days and "on" other days.
Besides that -we are called to read the Scriptures for ourselves and "not add or take away". We need to be cautious about anyone who speculates and adds elements to God's Word, that haven't been recorded in History as "fact".
But, even beyond the point of making sure the Scriptures are accurately portrayed, we just need to be careful about putting people on pedestals; elevating them to dangerous heights in our own mind (and theirs).
I can think of people who have preached God's word for years and have remained known for the truth that they share; not for anything else. In fact, the men I'm thinking of are calm and matter of fact - not even dynamic. Yet, their teachings are solid.
But, when you think of Beth Moore - there is a certain feeling of
frenzy and excitement that comes along - like she's a celebrity in her field. To me, that's where the caution should come in. We don't need celebrities imparting wisdom to us about scripture. God has given us that ability for ourselves, in that He has given us the gift of His Spirit, to interpret His Word, as we read and seek Him.
I honestly think this is how women are misled. Can you think of any man that is totally enamored with another man's preaching, so much so, that he would travel for hours down the road, just to sit at that person's feet and soak up all he has to say? I can't.
Ladies, I just say
be careful. Be careful about putting all your trust into another human - whether it's the pastor in the pulpit on Sunday mornings or Beth Moore coming "to a church near you". God has given each one of us, as believers, His wisdom (when we ask), His counselor (Holy spirit), His time, His word - all at our fingertips.
It's ok to read the work of others and gain a different perspective. We all have a testimony, when walking with the King, on what HE has shown us and it's an awesome thing to share that, in hopes that someone will come along and grow because of what God has done in
our lives. However, we need to be sure we are hiding behind the cross and that the reflection people see when looking at us, is God, not some celebrity with all knowledge and wisdom. No one is worthy of that status, but Jesus.
So for those of you who are Beth Moore fans, I apologize for stepping on your toes. This is just my perspective and you can take it our leave it. After all, I'm just merely flesh and bone, giving an opinion. I'm not a celebrity and I don't play one in real life.
Have a great weekend!